Beware of the NGOs that come with money to silence the poor
on November 26, 2007
Category: Social Movements, South Africa
Shackdwellers International (SDI) is USAID funded NGO created to set up and support shackdweller organisations around the world. In other words shut them up. The South African branch of the SDI works closely with the local and national government and we all know how supportive they have been of the shackdweller movement in Durban, Cape Town, Johannesburg and the rural areas. Enter the Gates Foundation with a $10million handout to help the South African government put an end to the shackdwellers movement.
Abahlali baseMjondolo have responded to SDI, the Bill Gates Foundation and the latest scheme to silence and kill off the poor.
We have a clear analysis on what the money that our government and the Gates Foundation have given SDI is for. It is true that some of it will go to build houses. But it is important to remember that there are two kinds of houses. Some houses are built in human dumping grounds outside of the cities and people are forced to go to these houses against their will. In these houses people sometimes just rot. These houses are often worse for people than shacks. They are a kind of oppression just like forced removal to townships outside the cities was a kind of oppression under apartheid. Other houses are planed with people and are built where people need them. In these houses people can grow. If Gate’s $10 millions builds some of the right kind of houses we will welcome them as fruits of the long struggles of Abahlali baseMjondolo, the Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign, the Landless People’s Movement and all the communities that have been blockading roads and organising protests around the country for the last few years. These protests have created such a crisis that the government here, and its supporters outside, recognise that something has to be done. Therefore the houses built will be fruits of struggle even though they will not be given to the people who have struggled. They will be a reward for obedience. This is how things work. We therefore see the risk that these fruits of struggle will be used to try and persuade people in movements and organisations that struggle to give up their autonomy and to cease struggling which means to stop thinking and to stop demanding the right of ordinary people to also be able to plan the
future of our cities.It is clear to us that everyone wants to speak and act in the name of the poor but that very, very few organisations are willing to speak to the poor. At first the government wanted the councillors to speak for us. Most times this failed completely. Most times the councillors spoke for the rich in their wards. If the ratepayer’s association wanted shack dwellers chased out of a ward and the shack dwellers wanted houses built in that ward the councillor would work with the ratepayers’ association to chase the shack dwellers out. This is why we buried out councillors in 2005. This is why people have been protesting against their councillors all over the country. The councillors have failed the poor and they continue to fail the poor – right now in Motala Heights both the Ward Councillor (Dimba) and the PR Councillor (Naranjee) are working with the gangster businessman Ricky Govender to chase the poor out of Motala Heights.
Tags:
Shackdwellers;
Durban + South Africa
Abahlali baseMjondolo;
Bill Gates Foundation
Shackdwellers International


Trackback URL for this post:
http://www.blacklooks.org/2007/11/beware_of_the_ngos_that_come_with_money_to_silence_the_poor.html/trackback
9 Comments so far
1. Nasra
November 26th, 2007 at 6:51 pm
You have been aalways a ture activist ..how wish I can learn from u
2. mwafrika
November 26th, 2007 at 7:57 pm
Any house is better than no house….
3. Sokari
November 26th, 2007 at 8:18 pm
mwafrika @ really! well there are thousands of shackdwellers that do not see it that way - what happened to rights and dignity or you think because people are poor they should be thankful for cardboard and zinc?
4. Hayah
November 27th, 2007 at 8:18 am
This is very intresting! It really gives one a different take on the NGO culture dosent it? I work in a women’s rights NGO myself and find the donor drivenn agenda stifling. How I wish Asia and Afica could sustain without the donors and their money.
I’m very glad to find this blog!! great job! keep writing!!
5. Victor Maritim
November 27th, 2007 at 9:06 am
It is true that in their quest to get donor money, NGOs forget about who they are supposed to be trying to help in the first place.
and @Mwafrika you can never say that any house is better than no house.. even the most downtrodden have dignity. Mostly this happens when a estate for the rich is thought to be too near to a slum or a slum is growing too fast. Where these guys go is not given a thought even if it is the dumpsite! ‘afterall don’t they now have a house!’ is the thinking there.
6. SuperWeed » Blog Archive » Black Looks and Swarming Thoughts
November 29th, 2007 at 7:41 pm
[…] these are constructed and manipulated by culture.” Recent posts have covered topics such as deceptive anti-poverty projects, police repression of LGBT activists in Uganda, and the ongoing 16 days of activism against gender […]
7. darkdaughta
November 29th, 2007 at 9:51 pm
I think that the time is long overdue for us denizens of different interlocking communities to look at the impact of corporate funded, mostly wealthy family, foundation or right wing funded agencies cropping up around the world. If the board or advisors for an NGO is made up of bankers, convservative lawyers, civil servants and the like, how does this define the left or progressive agenda of an agency? As you’ve pointed out, won’t silence be woven into the docs that define how the money is spent or dispersed? Won’t a marked decrease in lack of rebellion be a condition of support?
8. Black Looks
December 3rd, 2007 at 2:02 pm
[…] update on the Shackdwellers International (SDI) and the high jacking of social movements by NGOs. The Western Cape Anti Eviction Campaign have issued an open letter to the Social Movements Indaba […]
9. Books of the Twentieth Century » Blog Archive » Comment on Beware of the NGOs that come with money to silence the …
December 3rd, 2007 at 5:48 pm
[…] Comment on Beware of the NGOs that come with money to silence the …By Black Looksupdate on the Shackdwellers International (SDI) and the high jacking of social movements by NGOs. The Western Cape Anti Eviction Campaign have issued an open letter to the Social Movements Indaba […]Comments for Black Looks - http://www.blacklooks.org […]